This is how I make my judgement while editing and reviewing new or old Creepypastas:

1.Every incorrectly spelled word will be fixed,unless it was intentional.

2.I don't care whether or not your a new writer. If your pasta sucks,I'm gonna spit it in your face.

3.If you have a unfinished pasta,I'll tell you,politely,to get the fuck out.Confucious said,plan ahead.

And that's basically all there is.So really all you have to do to not get a bad review,is to use your brain.There's a reason why you were born with one.