So what would you consider to be the worst Creepypasta? I'll take votes for the pasta here.
- No Sonic.exe, since almost everyone would pick that. This wouldn't be interesting if it was allowed on this list.
- You don't have to choose a pasta on this list.
- You can choose pastas that have been deleted from the CP wiki, but the pasta must have been on this wiki for over a week.
Votes (Click on the pastas to read them): Edit
Baby Blue - 1
BEN Drowned - 3
Blood Whistle - 1
Happy Appy - 1
Jane the Killer - 9
Jeff the Killer - 8
Ticci Toby - 1