What is the most scary, creepy, haunting creepypasta you've ever read? Have you ever read a pasta that kept you up at night, or read one that you had to stop reading due to the unbearable dread building in your brain as you read?
Personally for me, the scariest pasta I've ever read has to be "The Puppetmaster's Regime". As I read it, I was shaking and jumping at every sound I read. As the story progressed and got worse and worse, I began to sink into my chair, wishing that it was over but still continuing to read on. I will never forget that one.
The first creepypasta that REALLY scared me was "Squidward's Suicide." I know people give it a lot of hate, but the gruesome imagery, and reading about a show I grew up watching being so twisted, and then SEEING THAT THERE WAS A VIDEO AT THE BOTTOM gave me a shock and horror that kept me up. Just knowing that there was a video kept me up.
The image of Smile Dog kept popping up in my head at the worst times. Can't ever forget it now.
After listening to MrCreepypasta's reading of "The Rake" I had trouble sleeping. I couldn't get the image of The Rake out of my mind for a awhile.
All of the pasta's I've mentioned I read a long time ago, and I used to get scared pretty easily. I would love to hear which pastas keep you up, or at least stick with you long after you read them.