While I was browsing through the wikia, picked up some stories that deserve far more attention than they currently are.

Perfect Circle

The Pastel Man


A Long Detour


A Simple Demonic Ritual

Some older stories I read that also deserve attention:

The Quarantine

Something Is Wrong

The Last Job

Stay in Bed

In the Woods

The Gym Teacher

A Perfect Memory

All I could think of now. If you can, add more underrated pastas in the comment section! I'm tired of reading pastas like Dead Bart, Mr. Mix, and Normal Porn for Normal People, it's just getting dull. So, check these pastas out!