Creepypastas based on old WWF wrestlers. Now hear me out: I'm not exactly a big fan of wrestling, but as of late I've taken great interest in the private lives and stories told by wrestlers like Honky Tonk Man, Hulk Hogan, The Iron Sheik, Mr. Perfect etc. They were really interesting guys outside of wrestling and have many awesome drug-fueled funny stories.
Many of the most interesting wrestlers like Mr. Perfect, Macho Man Randy Savage, The Ultimate Warrior, Rowdy Roddy Piper, Bret the Hitman Hart, all of whom have passed (some mysteriously) have been some of the most interesting.
Perhaps a cool reality-based pasta a-la Richard Pryor could be made out of some of this. Granted you may be wondering why I don't just do this myself instead of throwing the idea out there. The answer is simple: I am not good at making scary stories. This saddens me really as I've read soooo many and have read just about every well-known Creepypasta and then some. But I simply don't have the ability. I like the idea and would hate to see it wasted on my sub-par writing prowess so if you can craft a good story out of the topic... I'd love to see it :]