Creepypasta Wiki

Talk:My Little Pony Theory

Back to page

11,643pages on
this wiki

Can someone say wall? tl;dr A haunting, murderous cliché. 02:37, May 16, 2012 (UTC)

I absolutely hate theorys, but this one, this one was really sad, I enjoyed it, it's not true, obviously, but it's nice, It's sad, and I can imagine Lauren Faust to do something like this to people.

I'm in search of myself. Have you seen me anywhere? 22:30, May 18, 2012 (UTC)

How do people find out one of the girls was killed from the voices telling her she could fly when she died? MeganPepper 00:15, May 21, 2012 (UTC)

Yeah, that part bugged me too. VISUALSHOCK! SPEEDSHOCK! SOUNDSHOCK! NOW IS TIME TO THE 68000 HEART ON FIRE! 00:20, May 21, 2012 (UTC)

Oh wow... pinkie pie's death is insane... O_o

       Above by Pump90656

1 problem....most of the ponies were invented in the old series and had the same personelities ~~unicornz101~~

A good horror story takes at least a small time to tell. If this is too long for you to read, go back to twitter. I loved this theory though, but I agree with the last two users. Really, how are you supposed to know what the voices were saying when it's in her head? A small blunder though, one that every good writer makes from time to time.Cruel-quillish 04:24, June 5, 2012 (UTC)

This is really good~ It makes you think , what if the ponys were based of the kids.... Even if this is not true , I loved it all the same :] - Dana - (talk) 14:21, August 3, 2012 (UTC)

All right. This story garnered a mixed response from me. I think its worst aspect is that it diesn't do well for my willing suspension of disbelief. Not only would a newspaper most definitely not be that detailed, but the concept of a story just completely disappearing off the face of the Earth, save for what your friend saved on a flash drive? I don't buy it. Regardless, the end touched into an interesting possibility, and it was very muchso enjoyable, even if it was obviously fake. It almost reminds me of theories about Yume Nikki--they don't really make sense, but they don't have to to be chilling. Overall, not a bad job! --Ryonne (talk) 19:42, August 7, 2012 (UTC)

i wanna find the news article that he is talking about...

Dinkywinky (talk) 01:58, September 10, 2012 (UTC)deven

I have to igonore the "I ran into this news article" setup, because obviously even if there were six deaths on the same day (and, let's be honest, more than six people probably die in any given day you care to mention) a newspaper wouldn't run an in-depth story on them as a group when there's clearly no correlation. That aside, though, I thought that the stories told seemed credible enough, even barring just happening to know why "Pinkie Pie" jumped. The idea of the series being crafted as a way to give a group of wayward souls the happiness they didn't get in life was a good one, and it was told quite effectively. I am a little reminded of other theorypastas, like the "Ed, Edd, and Eddie takes place in Purgatory" one, but it didn't feel too terribly cliched, and tying the characters to real-life people was actually pretty compelling. Most of all, though, it was unsettling and morbid without being gory and dark. In other words, it was legitimately creepy, so high marks from me.

Kefke Wren (talk) 06:36, December 24, 2012 (UTC)


Those were some pretty in depth news articles... FullOnFedora (talk) 07:29, December 2, 2012 (UTC)

I was crying a little as I was reading "Fluttershy's" story and the Pinkie Pie one. Why does it has to be part of a children's show? Now everything that has happen (Pinkie's depression and Twilights paranoia) does make sense but the question still remain. Why do this? Swoomzie (talk) 21:27, January 25, 2013 (UTC)


Do some 1 has the link to the News Story he read???

Trying to found out as much as i can :)

Jonawar (talk) 21:38, February 21, 2013 (UTC)

This made me cry... i was sad. Not like any other theory i read. It was great!!!!!!!!! AnnieCresta-Odair20 (talk) 21:04, April 3, 2013 (UTC)AnnieCresta-Odair20AnnieCresta-Odair20 (talk) 21:04, April 3, 2013 (UTC)

I have some ideas!

This is creepypasta not sad pasta!!!

To make this creepier add some garbage about Faust selling the souls of the girls to some supernatural entity for sucess as she sold her own soul for her earlier sucess. Also does the name Faust

If you want to narm it up , add some slander about removing the soul of Fighting is Magic just so she can have a role in it!

Is there a Foster's home for imaginary friends theory creepypasta ? Blix1ms0ns (talk) 05:58, April 18, 2013 (UTC)

Online essays during that late 80s? That takes lots of suspension of disbelief. Get "Twilight" to memorize an essay from a book and "Pinkie Pie" telling her psychologist about her halucinations along with a suicide note. Blix1ms0ns (talk) 10:47, April 25, 2013 (UTC)

i don't mean to start any trouble at all but can you please change it back to 2004? or 2005?

it'd be better if it was later, lauren faust wasnt even making cartoons in the 80s. how would she hear of this story?

Joe Thecreeper (talk) 22:21, May 31, 2013 (UTC)Joe Thecreeper

None of the characters in the story died on the day mentioned. Here is a list of everybody who died. FicticiousAnimation (talk) 14:00, June 14, 2013 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki