The story takes place in New Mobotropolis, Mobius. This is the universe from the Sonic The Hedgehog Archie Comics.
Cream the Rabbit is a supposed sweet innocent little rabbit who loves to 'Make' friends. But when hero Sonic The Hedgehog is offered to make her a 'Stuffed Buddy' he has no idea what he's in for.
This story was inspired somewhat by the 'Cupcakes' MLP:FiM creepypasta. It is not ment to be an exact copy of it, but some things might have some similarities.
It was like any other normal day in New Mobotropolis. Mobians were about in their work and such, leaving many children alone to play with one another. Eggman hadn’t attacked the city in ages and Snively hadn’t been a threat either. It was like the two threats were dead, no longer a problem.
On the other hand, a very fast blue hedgehog had been speeding around the city with a familiar two-tailed fox. The two had been spending the whole busy morning playing flag tag. Time had passed by so quickly Sonic hadn’t realized the time.
“Sonic don’t you have a ‘play date’ with Cream?” Tails snickered playfully. Sonic sighed rolling his green eyes.
“Actually I do. I promised her I would help her build a stuffed animal. She said it was something like Build-A-Bear-Workshop, but you can do it yourself at home.”
Tails nodded and flicked his twin tails in understanding.
“Well you best not be late for your ‘date’!”
Tails laughed as he had started to slowly glide away, spinning his two tails in the air and lifting his body up through the windy current. Sonic had heaved yet another sigh this time with a bored groan. Today he was going to play with a little girl. How ‘mature’ of him.
As he slowly made his way over to her house, she was waiting outside for him. Smiling she bounced over to him holding something in a basket.
“Hello Cream, I hope I’m not late.” Sonic chuckled lightly. She simply grinned happily and blinked back at the taller blue hedgehog.
“No of course not! Your right on time! I even made you some cookies!” Sonic’s ears flicked as he smiled, watching the young bunny pulling out a giant chocolate chip cookie. She held it out in front of the hedgehog, watching as he slowly took it and observed it’s delicious looking figure.
“Go on! Eat it! I made it with lots of love!” Sonic couldn’t beat a deal like that, lightly nodding and taking a bite. After swallowing it he started to feel a bit sick.
“Cream, mind if I go inside and lie down? I just got a major migraine.” Cream nodded happily as she took his hand, pulling him into the hut. Inside, there was a soft looking couch and a few pillows scattered about on the cushions.
“Lie down and rest, okay? As soon as your finished Mr. Sonic, we’ll build the best friend ever!” Sonic coughed lightly as jumped onto the couch, immediately falling asleep.
When Sonic had woken up after a long rest, he could feel his head pounding.
“What the hell did I have to eat before?” Sonic went to go rub his head for relief, when he noticed he was stuck stiff.
“The heck?!” Sonic attempted to squirm, only for his body to stay completely still. He looked down to see tight rope and electrical tape around his ankles. When he moved his gaze up to his wrists, he also saw the same thing. Looking behind him, he could see a table, a wooden one with a cute tablecloth of bunnies and chao lying there. On top of it was a white cloth covering a tray.
His neck had been tied also, barely making him able to speak. He could feel himself up against a wall of sorts, with holes in the back of it allowing his quills through. Where was he?
“Hehe! You’re finally awake Mr. Sonic!” Sonic looked right in front of him to see little, bright Cream grinning about. She was standing up against his stomach looking up to his face.
“Uhh, hello Cream. Where am I?” She giggled her usual sweet, innocent laugh, and bounced back a few inches.
“It’s my play room! All my best friends come here to play!” Sonic blinked confused. It was utterly dark in here and there weren’t any usual play things in sight.
“Oh how rude of me!” Cream exclaimed as she saw Sonic’s confused expression. She walked over to a panel with buttons on it and giggled, pressing in the fourth one from the left. Sonic’s eyes blinked and winced as the bright light flickered on, illuminating the whole room. The hedgehog’s eyes widened in horror at what he had witnessed before him.
“Do you like it?” Cream asked pointing to the set of corpses lying around. One he saw in familiar was bald, with three set of hairs on top. He choked out in complete shock.
“Snively?!” Cream giggled again, moving around some stuff to reveal a headless figure with a bushy mustache. Sonic immediately recognized the militated head to be none other than Dr. Robotnik’s. It was lying lifelessly on top of a metal tray covered in dark red blood, next to the head of Snively. Both of their eyes were hollowed out some veins from the previous eyes that had been held there hung out, scrunched up from no blood flow. No wonder Snively and Eggman hadn't been attacking the city in so long! They were here, bodyless!
“Like my new best friends?” She asked again, much deeper in monologue. Tears started to fight their way out of the hedgehog’s eyes as he recognized another body. It was his friend Tails’s old classmate, Rory, lying on the ground next to the two headless bodies.
“Cream, what happened to those three?” Sonic asked shockingly as he was now full of pure fear. The creamy pelted bunny laughed lightly, walking back over to Sonic.
“Well that silly doctor and his nephew were very bad. I thought after I invited them over for a tea party I could teach them how to be nice! So far it’s worked! Both of them haven’t said a word since they got here!”
“That’s because they’re freaking dead!” Cream’s smile quickly faded as she looked at the yelling hedgehog.
“That’s not very nice language, Sonic. ‘Freaking’ is a bad word,” She calmly, yet creepily, replied back.
“Yeah well, you’re a freaking physcopath! Look at poor Rory! Why would you do that, Cream?” Cream just giggled again and went behind the hedgehog. Sonic’s adrenaline started to pulse throughout his body as more fear flooded over his mind.
“Well Rory’s my friend silly! He promised me he would make a stuffed buddy with me! See?” Sonic started to try and break free, only for the tape and rope to go tighter around his wrists and ankles.
“Well don’t you need stuffing and an animal to make a stuffed animal friend?” Sonic asked, trying to stall the young girl. Cream sighed and giggled, yet again.
“Well you need the hollow animal buddy first!” She exclaimed happily.
“Where exactly would you get it?” Sonic asked, dreading the answer.
“Simple. I get it from you!” Sonic stopped, praying he heard her wrong. What did she mean ‘Get it from you?’
“What do you mean ‘Get it from me’?” He asked gulping and she moved closer to his back. She grinned, pulling off the cloth from the table behind him to reveal different medical tools. Some had a red-black crust around the handles, showing that they weren’t exactly new.
“Well by hollowing you out silly!” Sonic gasped loudly and watched as she took a scalpel from the table. Sweat started to slowly make its way down the side of his head, soaking most if not all, of his fur. He knew he couldn’t escape, so maybe trying option B would work.
“Cream, you can’t do this! I’m your friend!”
“I know silly! That’s why I want you to always be around me for a long, long, time.” Sonic bit his lower lip in frustration as she looked at the scalpel, grinning.
“But everyone would notice I was gone! Who would help stop evil from taking over the planet?” Cream giggled again, walking much closer.
“Don’t be silly. That’s a job left for the other Freedom Fighters!” Sonic started to hyperventilate as she went back behind him.
“Please, Cream! Let me go! I want to go home! Look, I won’t tell anyone if you let me go. I’ll even buy you any plush stuffed animal you want! You name it you got it, please…” Cream only smiled lightly as she yanked back on the blue hedgehog’s quills located on his middle back area. Those were his most valuable ones and they were the same ones that kept him safe.
“Please don’t do this, Cream!” Sonic cried out as she still held back his quills.
“I’m sorry, Sonic, but you were next on my list! I want you to always be here for me! You’re like my big brother!” Quickly before Sonic could reply, she sliced down the sharp scalpel against the hedgehog’s back and accidently peeled off more than she wanted to. The quills, still attached to his back, hung off of the new fresh wound that she made. Sonic screamed out in pain and fear as she yanked at them again, pulling nearly the whole fur and skin on his back off. His muscles pulsed and tightened as he finally had a bit of freedom to move now, squirming helplessly.
“Stop moving! Now see what happened? I cut off a bit too much! Oh well, I’m good at sewing, so we’ll fix that up later,” she giggled half-heartedly again. Sonic’s head was starting to pound in pain as her giggles kept going and going, keeping him still in shock and fear of what she would do next. As if she read his mind, she made another incision down his back to the base of his tail, making his squirm in pain again.
“Princess Sally was right! You don’t listen!” She yelled half surprised and half angry. Sonic was biting his lip harder, regretting ever coming over to ‘play’ with Cream. Maybe right now someone was hearing them or Tails was looking for him. But no one would come to save the hedgehog right now as the rabbit continued about her little ‘game’. All Sonic could do behind tears and shivering was look at the head of his former nemesis for some sort of comfort.
“Now, let’s get off the troublesome tail! We’ll put on a prettier one later!” Sonic’s ears flattened. She wasn’t, she couldn’t!
Oh but she did as she grabbed a nearby butcher knife, quickly hacking it down and chopping off the hedgehog’s tail. Sonic screamed out in pain loudly as he felt blood start to rush from the stump that had been left after his tail fell to the floor. Cream sighed and yanked back on the quills connected to the hedgehog’s head.
“If you thought that was painful, you’re in for a real shock. You should really man up, Sonic. The Sonic I knew was much tougher and braver than this.” Sonic couldn’t even reply behind screams as she started to yank harder and harder on his quills. Was this how he was going to die? In the hands of a little, supposed innocent girl?
“Stop screaming! How would you like if you invited your best friend over, only to have them scream over and over! Stop being so disrespectful!” Sonic could hear a huge tear as she pulled out one of his quills. He bit his lip again, trying not to scream out. If he did, she would probably pull out more of his precious quillery.
“Please…” He managed to sob. “I want to go home!” But Cream only shook her head displeased. She walked back to the front of him and stared into his eyes menacingly.
“I invited you over, only you! You should be so happy we’re spending your last moments together! You wouldn’t have been like this for Tails!” Sonic tried to reply back, only for more sobs to break through. This girl was a total monster, killing innocent (mostly other than Eggman and Snively) people for fun. As Sonic slumped back, his back rubbed off some of the wall behind him, sending him into a fit of shrieking.
It felt like someone was stabbing him over and over and over again. Cream had frowned again this time and decided that she should get this finally over with. The more he screamed, the more Cream would get annoyed. Looking to her right she had seen a saw lying on the ground next to the table. She smiled, remembering it was the same one she had used many times before. It broke bones open with ease, so she wouldn’t have any issues.
“Now hold still, Sonic…this is going to hurt, oh…a lot!” She picked up the saw, revving it to a normal bucking sound. Sonic’s eyes widened as his mouth gaped open, the shadow of Cream and her saw stretching over him. Her grin was wicked as her beautiful blue eyes started to grow smaller and smaller.
“Please C-Cream! No!” Sonic pleaded once again, but his moans for relief were drowned out by the humming of the saw. Sonic squeezed his eyes shut as he heard the humming getting closer and closer until finally, he could feel the buzz of sharp, metal teeth, rip through his muscles. Cream had started to move down from Sonic’s left shoulder all the way down to his stomach, ending at his crotch. Sonic could only shiver as blood splattered onto the wall next to him and her evil soul filled body. The once beautiful cream colored dress was now drenched in the dark warm liquid from Sonic’s inner body.
“N-Na,” Sonic whispered out as she stopped the saw and ripped open his chest. Inside behind his now crushed ribs, lied his pulsing heart. It beat with great intensity as his whole body went numb from reality. His sight started to blur, and the last thing he could see or feel was Cream ripping out his body parts, starting with the intestines and liver, moving up to his lungs, and last but not least his heart. She placed her blood-covered hands on his pounding heart and smiled.
“See it, Sonic? It’s your heart…isn’t it just beautiful?” Sonic couldn’t reply as he lost his consciousness. Cream sighed sadly and ripped it out, slinging it back onto the tray across the room. With one last gasp of breath, the hedgehog’s mouth gaped open as his head fell to the side. He was finally gone after so much excruciating pain.
“Oh, well that wasn’t much fun as I hoped.” Cream stated sadly as she looked at her lifeless friend. But then a smile came to her face, slowly escalating into a very evil grin.
“But now I’ll fix him up into my Plush Buddy forever and ever to play with! It’s too bad I have no one else to play with except…” Cream gasped happily as she got another idea.
“Maybe I can have more friends! I know! I’ll ask the Freedom Fighters to help make Stuffed Buddies with me! They can’t say no to me! And then I’ll have so many friends!” Cream bounced up and down squeaking happily as she realized her great idea.
“Now,” she said speaking to no one in particular. “Let’s fix you up, Sonic,” she giggled cutely picking up a thread and needle, leaning over the limp hedgehog’s body.